Yasmina Vinci writes: Head Start Leads the Way in Quality Pre-K

by Yasmina Vinci, Executive Director, NHSA

Enrollment in state-funded preschool programs has more than doubled in the past 15 years, but an annual report released today by the National Institute for Early Education Research (NIEER) reveals that one of the defining aspects of Head Start — high-quality standards — is missing from many state-funded preschool programs. What’s more, many of those that are succeeding are doing so in part because of their strong collaboration with Head Start programs and/or because they have aligned their standards with the Head Start Program Performance Standards.

Read between the lines and the message is clear: Head Start is leading the way in demonstrating how to provide consistently high-quality pre-K that improves outcomes for children in kindergarten and beyond.

Even though Head Start is fundamentally a federal-to-local program in terms of funding, state leaders have sought to partner with Head Start programs within their states in order to increase both the quality of their preschool initiatives and the number of three- and four-year old children they can reach. In fact, one of the states highlighted by the NIEER report, Mississippi, has integrated Head Start into its state pre-K system and most of the state’s Early Learning Collaboratives include Head Start programs and teachers.

In West Virginia — which NIEER dubs one of the “six states to watch” — the report observes that the state has largely achieved the goal of universal pre-K while maintaining high standards through “an unusually strong and well-coordinated collaboration” among education, child care, and Head Start agencies. Far from simply providing another revenue stream for state preschool initiatives, Head Start has played a leadership role in this systemic coordination through the Head Start state collaboration offices, state associations, and local programs.

Head Start is also guiding the way for how states can resolve one of the most troubling findings of the report: the lack of consistency from state to state in providing preschool-aged children with the quality classroom experiences they need to get ready for kindergarten. NIEER outlines 10 quality benchmarks in the report and they largely align with the Head Start Program Performance Standards and Early Learning Outcomes Framework — requirements that every Head Start program across the nation must meet. These include standards like ensuring that children receive vision, hearing, and other health screenings and referrals; requiring degrees and credentials for teaching staff; mandating professional development and coaching for both lead and assistant teachers; and implementing a continuous quality improvement system so that information is gathered regularly on processes and outcomes and used to guide program improvements.

It is also telling that many of the states that have expanded their pre-K enrollment over the past 15 years have aligned their quality standards with the Head Start Performance Standards. Clearly, Head Start is a model to which both national experts and state education leaders are turning when looking for best practices in high-quality preschool initiatives.

One major conclusion missing from the NIEER report is where states stand on achieving the primary goal of their preschool initiatives: creating stronger outcomes for children. On this point, Head Start’s record of success is evident. In fact, in Mississippi — one of the states highlighted in NIEER’s press release about the report — children who had attended Head Start were among the top groups in terms of growth during kindergarten. While it’s true that the vulnerable children Head Start serves often have more ground to make up, the high-quality nature of Head Start’s early learning programs is succeeding at closing the gap.

Greater kindergarten readiness is only part of the picture. Recent research has found a wide range of outstanding short-, intermediate-, and long-term child and family outcomes among Head Start participants. Stronger cognitive, vocabulary, behavioral and social and emotional skills. More parent involvement. Reduced foster care placement rates. Lower rates of grade repetition by 8th grade. Less chronic absenteeism in middle school. Greater high school graduation rates. Increased higher education enrollment and completion rates. Lower incarceration rates. Higher lifetime earnings. These are just a few of the lifelong benefits children are gaining through the Head Start Advantage.

This year’s NIEER report includes a new focus on dual language learners, another population of children that benefits from Head Start’s high-quality services. In fact, about a third of Head Start children are dual language learners. The Head Start Act, Program Performance Standards, and Early Learning Outcomes Framework all require that Head Start programs work to meet the needs of dual language learners. This focus is reaping results. At least one study — a Congressionally-mandated government report — confirms that dual language learners made greater improvements in English vocabulary development after a year of Head Start than did their monolingual peers.

NIEER is to be applauded for taking a hard look at what is working and what is not in state-funded preschool. Head Start is proud to be a leader in our nation’s collaborative effort to provide high-quality, evidence-based early childhood development and education to every young child.

 

March

(ANN ARBOR, Mich.) - When Stacey Bess drove up to her first classroom as a newbie teacher, she thought she had taken a wrong turn. Before her was a rusted shed amidst a clutter of overturned railcars spilled out under a highway viaduct. Bess' first assignment was novel indeed - an experimental, pilot program for children staying in a nearby homeless shelter in Salt Lake City, Utah. For the next eight years, Bess learned to love and care for her students in the most life-affirming and life-…

February

(EAST LANSING, Mich.) Talent pools are shrinking, budgets are tight and the work is hard.  How do we recruit and retain talent when resources are limited? The answer to these questions and much more were tackled by MHSA's Human Resources Learning Community on Feb. 15, 2018 with visiting HR expert and presenter Jodi Schafer. Schafer, a senior HR professional and owner of Human Resources Management Services, led a frank conversation about research and reality in "Grow Your Own Talent Programs…

January

(NOVI, Mich.) - The Michigan Head Start Association's 2018 Winter Assembly and Election provided an information-rich program on January 11-12 on topics including: addressing trauma in children and families, legislative updates from statewide experts and a visit from the soon-to-be newest member of the Michigan Department of Education (MDE) administration. Dr. Scott Koenigsknecht, the incoming Deputy Superintendent of MDE's P-20 Systems and Student Transition, attended a comprehensive briefing…

December

WASHINGTON, DC – The National Head Start Association (NHSA) today applauded an announcement from the Administration that it will reevaluate a regulation that NHSA has long argued is ineffective, arbitrary, and unnecessarily burdensome on Head Start programs. Earlier today, the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services released an official request for comments on a proposal that would change the Designation Renewal System’s (DRS) use of the CLASS tool, including the removal of the arbitrary…

November

LANSING, MI - Unlike children’s book character Officer Buckle, Ingham County Sheriff Scott Wriggelsworth would never stand on a swivel chair for better reach. That’s safety lesson number 77, he told a lively group of giggling preschoolers at Maplehill Head Start this week. But like the mishap-prone hero in “Officer Buckle and Gloria,” who takes a fall and goes on to teach children about safety with help from his police dog Gloria, Wriggelsworth said he also employs police dogs in the line of…

September

Dear Colleague, As we all know from the heart-breaking news in Texas and Louisiana this week, deadly Hurricane Harvey has claimed dozens of lives and left thousands homeless and in need of rescue. Now the long road to recovery begins. In this vein, I ask for your help in support of the National Head Start Association's effort to assist our Head Start children, families, and their communities in these battered states. Please join the Michigan Head Start Association by contributing to the NHSA'…

August

(August 10, 2017) Huffington Post -- Effective use of federal funding is imperative to meet the needs of America’s most vulnerable early learners. To ensure those precious public resources are efficiently spent, Congressional leaders regularly (and rightly) ask about potential fragmentation, overlap and duplication of the various federal programs providing early care and education. Last month, Congress’ oversight arm, the Government Accountability Office (GAO), examined these questions and…

June

FiveCap Celebrates its Head Start Parents; They Rack up Huge Numbers in Volunteer Service Hours Ludington, Mich. (June 2, 2017) – It was a night to celebrate Head Start parents – and what a night it was!  What a celebration of success! Head Start/Early Head Start provider, FiveCap Inc. in northwest Michigan, hosted its 40th annual Parent and Volunteer Honors Banquet last week recognizing families for outstanding service.  Collectively, Head Start and Early Head Start parents in Newago, Lake…

May

Capital City Program Joins 1,400 Others Nationally in Community Reading Day LANSING, Mich. (May 18, 2018) – Wearing a “Reading is Magic” t-shirt and changing up her voice to mimic a parrot or pirate, dramatic story-teller Nicole Hansen brought the book “Pete the Pirate” alive for a Head Start classroom of 17 fascinated 4 year olds.  Each sporting a colorful pirate’s bandana, the children listened intently as Hansen described a pivotal plot twist in which a sunken pirate’s ship rises from the…

ALLEGAN COUNTY, Mich. (May 8, 2017) -- State Rep. Mary Whiteford on Monday visited a Head Start classroom at the Community Action of Allegan County, located at the local ACATEC (Allegan County Area Technical & Education Center). During her visit, Rep. Whiteford read “Ordinary Mary’s Extraordinary Deed” to the children, toured the facility, and met with staff to discuss early childhood education. “Head Start offers a unique two-generation educational approach which not only focuses on…